Description
Juxtaposing Muslim scholars' debates over women's attendance in mosques with historical descriptions of women's activities within Middle Eastern and North African mosques, Marion Holmes Katz shows how over the centuries legal scholars' arguments have often reacted to rather than dictated Muslim women's behavior.
Tracing Sunni legal positions on women in mosques from the second century of the Islamic calendar to the modern period, Katz connects shifts in scholarly terminology and argumentation to changing constructions of gender. Over time, assumptions about women's changing behavior through the lifecycle gave way to a global preoccupation with sexual temptation, which then became the central rationale for limits on women's mosque access. At the same time, travel narratives, biographical dictionaries, and religious polemics suggest that women's usage of mosque space often diverged in both timing and content from the ritual models constructed by scholars. Katz demonstrates both the concrete social and political implications of Islamic legal discourse and the autonomy of women's mosque-based activities. She also examines women's mosque access as a trope in Western travelers' narratives and the evolving significance of women's mosque attendance among different Islamic currents in the twentieth century.
About the Author
Marion Holmes Katz is a professor of Middle Eastern and Islamic studies at New York University. Her books include The Birth of the Prophet Muhammad: Devotional Piety in Sunni Islam (2007), Prayer in Islamic Thought and Practice (2013), and Wives and Work: Islamic Law and Ethics Before Modernity (Columbia, 2022).
Reviews
A scholarly milestone. Women in the Mosque is a comprehensive, categorical treatment of the question of women's mosque access in Islamic law and history. Marion Holmes Katz is one of the most widely respected scholars of Islamic law and ritual in the West, and, in its scope and detail, this work is peerless to my knowledge. -- Jonathan Brown, Georgetown University
Women in the Mosque will become an essential part of the library of every scholar concerned with Islamic ritual law, women in religion, women in Islam, and even religious architecture. There is something here for students of Islamic law, Ottoman history, Arab social history, and modern Muslim intellectual history. -- Kevin Reinhart, Dartmouth College
Marion Holmes Katz brings to light and adds context to the fascinating history of women's access to mosques through a dexterous presentation of a wide range of legal sources, travel accounts, contemporaneous Christian and Jewish accounts, literature, and a unique sixteenth-century manuscript recounting when women contested the ruling authorities' attempt to ban them from Islam's most sacred mosque in Mecca. A must-read for anyone interested in a solid historical account related to issues of women and gender in Islam. -- Intisar A. Rabb, Harvard Law School, and director of the Islamic Legal Studies Program
This is an extremely detailed, nuanced and precise account of women's presence in the mosque over the centuries. * Journal of Islamic Studies *
This book is praiseworthy for its extensive use of textual sources, making it an excellent source for the study of intellectual discourse on women's mobility and visibility in Islam. * Journal of the American Academy of Religion *
One of the most significant contributions to Muslim women's history and to Islamic legal studies in recent decades...pioneering and magisterial. * Der Islam *
A highly scholarly work on an important but oft-ignored aspect of women in Islam. * The Islamic Quarterly *
Extraordinary... a rich, in-depth, and often amusing analysis of the legal debates and social records of women's mosque attendance from the eighth to the early twenty-first century. * Journal of the Society for Contemporary Thought and the Islamicate World *
[An] extremely valuable book. -- Ruth Roded * Religion & Gender *
The book is of great importance to those interested in Muslim women's status, religious rights, and practice.... Highly recommended. * Choice *
Awards
Winner of AMEWS Book Award, Association for Middle East Women's Studies 2015.
Book Information
ISBN 9780231162678
Author Marion Katz
Format Paperback
Page Count 432
Imprint Columbia University Press
Publisher Columbia University Press
Tracing Sunni legal positions on women in mosques from the second century of the Islamic calendar to the modern period, Katz connects shifts in scholarly terminology and argumentation to changing constructions of gender. Over time, assumptions about women's changing behavior through the lifecycle gave way to a global preoccupation with sexual temptation, which then became the central rationale for limits on women's mosque access. At the same time, travel narratives, biographical dictionaries, and religious polemics suggest that women's usage of mosque space often diverged in both timing and content from the ritual models constructed by scholars. Katz demonstrates both the concrete social and political implications of Islamic legal discourse and the autonomy of women's mosque-based activities. She also examines women's mosque access as a trope in Western travelers' narratives and the evolving significance of women's mosque attendance among different Islamic currents in the twentieth century.
About the Author
Marion Holmes Katz is a professor of Middle Eastern and Islamic studies at New York University. Her books include The Birth of the Prophet Muhammad: Devotional Piety in Sunni Islam (2007), Prayer in Islamic Thought and Practice (2013), and Wives and Work: Islamic Law and Ethics Before Modernity (Columbia, 2022).
Reviews
A scholarly milestone. Women in the Mosque is a comprehensive, categorical treatment of the question of women's mosque access in Islamic law and history. Marion Holmes Katz is one of the most widely respected scholars of Islamic law and ritual in the West, and, in its scope and detail, this work is peerless to my knowledge. -- Jonathan Brown, Georgetown University
Women in the Mosque will become an essential part of the library of every scholar concerned with Islamic ritual law, women in religion, women in Islam, and even religious architecture. There is something here for students of Islamic law, Ottoman history, Arab social history, and modern Muslim intellectual history. -- Kevin Reinhart, Dartmouth College
Marion Holmes Katz brings to light and adds context to the fascinating history of women's access to mosques through a dexterous presentation of a wide range of legal sources, travel accounts, contemporaneous Christian and Jewish accounts, literature, and a unique sixteenth-century manuscript recounting when women contested the ruling authorities' attempt to ban them from Islam's most sacred mosque in Mecca. A must-read for anyone interested in a solid historical account related to issues of women and gender in Islam. -- Intisar A. Rabb, Harvard Law School, and director of the Islamic Legal Studies Program
This is an extremely detailed, nuanced and precise account of women's presence in the mosque over the centuries. * Journal of Islamic Studies *
This book is praiseworthy for its extensive use of textual sources, making it an excellent source for the study of intellectual discourse on women's mobility and visibility in Islam. * Journal of the American Academy of Religion *
One of the most significant contributions to Muslim women's history and to Islamic legal studies in recent decades...pioneering and magisterial. * Der Islam *
A highly scholarly work on an important but oft-ignored aspect of women in Islam. * The Islamic Quarterly *
Extraordinary... a rich, in-depth, and often amusing analysis of the legal debates and social records of women's mosque attendance from the eighth to the early twenty-first century. * Journal of the Society for Contemporary Thought and the Islamicate World *
[An] extremely valuable book. -- Ruth Roded * Religion & Gender *
The book is of great importance to those interested in Muslim women's status, religious rights, and practice.... Highly recommended. * Choice *
Awards
Winner of AMEWS Book Award, Association for Middle East Women's Studies 2015.
Book Information
ISBN 9780231162678
Author Marion Katz
Format Paperback
Page Count 432
Imprint Columbia University Press
Publisher Columbia University Press
