Description
A thoughtful consideration of the storytelling and science behind ancient DNA discoveries.
In recent years, discoveries brought to light through analysis of ancient DNA-or aDNA-have made headlines around the world. While ancient DNA studies may appear to focus on laboratory science and objective results, the findings have also relied heavily on storytelling and can be influenced by political interests.
In The Trouble with Ancient DNA, Anna Kallen explores how the parameters of genetic science influence the stories we tell about our ancient ancestors, questioning what narratives we can and should take at face value. Through accounts of migrations, warriors, and figures like Cheddar Man, we see enticing and potent narratives that reach far beyond what can be gathered from the scientific study of molecules alone. Rather, by privileging certain narratives and questions-like those about sex or eye and skin color-our stories of ancient DNA are spun around the structure of today's methodologies, technologies, and popular and political interests. Kallen considers how DNA is used to sensationalize stories, how its use poses questions of ethics and care, and who is responsible if stories of ancient DNA are adopted for dangerous political projects.
About the Author
Anna Kallen is professor and chair of museology at Umea University in Sweden. She is the author or editor of books including Stones Standing, The Archaeologist In-Between, Heritage and Borders, and Critical Perspectives on Ancient DNA.
Reviews
"Journalists and scientists have spread dubious historical narratives based on over-extrapolations from DNA evidence, according to this penetrating study. Kallen . . . explains the limits of collecting DNA from ancient bones and other archaeological finds, noting that the DNA is often so deteriorated that scientists can only recover less than 10% of the genome. . . . Shedding light on how geneticists' theories of the past often say more about themselves than their subjects, this provides plenty of food for thought." * Publishers Weekly *
"Kallen delves into how ancient DNA techniques have been implemented and interpreted in the context of human evolution, both within and outside the field. With The Trouble with Ancient DNA, she considers three broad applications of ancient DNA-large-scale migrations, genetic relationships between past and present populations, and phenotype reconstruction-looking closely at a series of case studies from existing literature and working to flesh out the societal impacts of such works, including the ways they've been co-opted to advance racist agendas." -- Maanasa Raghavan, The University of Chicago
"This one is a must-read! Geneticists have made an unfortunate habit of approaching the past with a twenty-first-century toolkit and a nineteenth-century mindset-and now they are getting called on it. This wonderfully stern examination of the interpretations of widely promoted ancient DNA data in archaeology shows that a technological revolution is quite separate from a scientific revolution. It will hopefully help to pull geneticists intellectually into the modern age, and to effect a real synthesis between the two classes of data." -- Jonathan Marks, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
"A timely, nuanced and much-needed analysis of the genomic revolution in the science of the past. DNA molecules are venerated in 'celebrity science' stories about charismatic imagined ancestors. Kallen's book is the perfect remedy for these 'just so' stories. She is the ideal travel companion for this journey into the weeds of what the science of paleogenetics can and cannot tell us about our past and why this matters." -- Emma Kowal, Deakin University
Book Information
ISBN 9780226821672
Author Anna Kallen
Format Hardback
Page Count 160
Imprint University of Chicago Press
Publisher The University of Chicago Press
Weight(grams) 454g
In recent years, discoveries brought to light through analysis of ancient DNA-or aDNA-have made headlines around the world. While ancient DNA studies may appear to focus on laboratory science and objective results, the findings have also relied heavily on storytelling and can be influenced by political interests.
In The Trouble with Ancient DNA, Anna Kallen explores how the parameters of genetic science influence the stories we tell about our ancient ancestors, questioning what narratives we can and should take at face value. Through accounts of migrations, warriors, and figures like Cheddar Man, we see enticing and potent narratives that reach far beyond what can be gathered from the scientific study of molecules alone. Rather, by privileging certain narratives and questions-like those about sex or eye and skin color-our stories of ancient DNA are spun around the structure of today's methodologies, technologies, and popular and political interests. Kallen considers how DNA is used to sensationalize stories, how its use poses questions of ethics and care, and who is responsible if stories of ancient DNA are adopted for dangerous political projects.
About the Author
Anna Kallen is professor and chair of museology at Umea University in Sweden. She is the author or editor of books including Stones Standing, The Archaeologist In-Between, Heritage and Borders, and Critical Perspectives on Ancient DNA.
Reviews
"Journalists and scientists have spread dubious historical narratives based on over-extrapolations from DNA evidence, according to this penetrating study. Kallen . . . explains the limits of collecting DNA from ancient bones and other archaeological finds, noting that the DNA is often so deteriorated that scientists can only recover less than 10% of the genome. . . . Shedding light on how geneticists' theories of the past often say more about themselves than their subjects, this provides plenty of food for thought." * Publishers Weekly *
"Kallen delves into how ancient DNA techniques have been implemented and interpreted in the context of human evolution, both within and outside the field. With The Trouble with Ancient DNA, she considers three broad applications of ancient DNA-large-scale migrations, genetic relationships between past and present populations, and phenotype reconstruction-looking closely at a series of case studies from existing literature and working to flesh out the societal impacts of such works, including the ways they've been co-opted to advance racist agendas." -- Maanasa Raghavan, The University of Chicago
"This one is a must-read! Geneticists have made an unfortunate habit of approaching the past with a twenty-first-century toolkit and a nineteenth-century mindset-and now they are getting called on it. This wonderfully stern examination of the interpretations of widely promoted ancient DNA data in archaeology shows that a technological revolution is quite separate from a scientific revolution. It will hopefully help to pull geneticists intellectually into the modern age, and to effect a real synthesis between the two classes of data." -- Jonathan Marks, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
"A timely, nuanced and much-needed analysis of the genomic revolution in the science of the past. DNA molecules are venerated in 'celebrity science' stories about charismatic imagined ancestors. Kallen's book is the perfect remedy for these 'just so' stories. She is the ideal travel companion for this journey into the weeds of what the science of paleogenetics can and cannot tell us about our past and why this matters." -- Emma Kowal, Deakin University
Book Information
ISBN 9780226821672
Author Anna Kallen
Format Hardback
Page Count 160
Imprint University of Chicago Press
Publisher The University of Chicago Press
Weight(grams) 454g
