Description
The Polish Underground and the Jews, 1939-1945 examines one of the central problems in the history of Polish-Jewish relations: the attitude and the behavior of the Polish Underground - the resistance organization loyal to the Polish government-in-exile - toward the Jews during World War II. Using a variety of archival documents, testimonies, and memoirs, Zimmerman offers a careful, dispassionate narrative, arguing that the reaction of the Polish Underground to the catastrophe that befell European Jewry was immensely varied, ranging from aggressive aid to acts of murder. By analyzing the military, civilian, and political wings of the Polish Underground and offering portraits of the organization's main leaders, this book is the first full-length scholarly monograph in any language to provide a thorough examination of the Polish Underground's attitude and behavior towards the Jews during the entire period of World War II.
Zimmerman examines the attitude and behavior of the Polish Underground towards the Jews during the Holocaust.
About the Author
Joshua D. Zimmerman is an Associate Professor of History and the Eli and Diana Zborowski Professorial Chair in Holocaust Studies and East European Jewish History at Yeshiva University in New York. He is the author of Poles, Jews and the Politics of Nationality: The Bund and the Polish Socialist Party in Late Tsarist Russia (2003) and the editor of two contributed volumes: Contested Memories: Poles and Jews during the Holocaust and its Aftermath (2003) and Jews in Italy under Fascist and Nazi Rule, 1922-1945 (Cambridge, 2005).
Reviews
'This is a superb history of one of the oddest episodes of World War II. Zimmerman has emerged as one of the best experts on the history of the controversial Polish-Jewish relations. His matter-of-fact style further dramatizes the Polish-Jewish affairs during World War II when the Polish underground army heroically fought against the Nazis, sometimes killing and sometimes helping the Jews who also participated in the anti-Nazi struggle. A shocking drama and a wonderfully researched, documented and written book - a real page-turner.' Ivan T. Berend, Distinguished Professor of History, University of California, Los Angeles
'Joshua D. Zimmerman has chosen to deal with an extremely controversial topic. He has carried out his task with great sensitivity and intelligence. The attitude of the Home Army to Jews was complicated, varying from time to time and also from place to place. On the basis of original sources, Zimmerman demonstrates how difficult it is to make generalizations about aspects of Polish-Jewish relations. This is an exciting and important book.' Peter Kenez, Emeritus Professor of History, University of California, Santa Cruz
'This well-researched and clearly written monograph deals with a very important but inadequately investigated topic - the reaction of the Armia Krajowa (Home Army) ... to the mass murder of the Jews carried out by Nazi Germany in Poland. Although the topic has aroused considerable controversy ... it has never been subject to a full scholarly investigation, making use of the large archival resources now available in Poland and abroad. This has now been accomplished by Professor Zimmerman. His approach is balanced and dispassionate and he consistently allows the documents to speak for themselves and to show all sides of a complex story. His book will, in my view, become the definitive account of the subject, which is crucial for an understanding the larger problem of the attitude of Polish society to the mass murder of Polish Jews carried out on Polish soil.' Antony Polonsky, Emeritus Professor of Holocaust Studies, Brandeis University, and Chief Historian, POLIN Museum of the History of Polish Jews, Warsaw
'Joshua Zimmerman's [book] is not only the most recent addition to the growing field of historical study of Polish-Jewish relations in World War II, but is also certainly the most complete in current literature. Brilliantly combining the divergent perspective of the Polish underground leadership and of the Jewish resistance, and accounting for their internal diversity, Zimmerman presents the stark choices each actor had to face, and why what was best to one was often seen as detrimental to the other. Skilfully combining analyses of pre-war and wartime Polish politics, military choices, anti-Semitism, the impact of the German genocide, and the perspective of liberation/occupation at the hands of the Soviets, as well as personal world-views of the individual commanders, the monograph explains why not enough help was forthcoming from the Polish side, and why Jews were perceived, and sometimes perceived themselves, as no longer being part of it.' Konstanty Gebert, Gazeta Wyborcza, Warsaw
'Zimmerman's book is a masterpiece. Zimmerman joins the ranks of other great Jewish historians who have published outstanding works on Polish-Jewish wartime relations free of prejudice.' Filip Mazurczak, Visegrad Insight
'[Zimmerman's] neutrality, painstaking dedication and fluency in Polish [has] helped him sift through the various cobwebs of perception on both sides and gain access to files others would never have found.' Haaretz (Haaretz.com)
'Zimmerman's book offers a balanced perspective, personalizing the topic by presenting profiles of several righteous individuals as well as unrepentant anti-Semites.' Steve Lipman, The Jewish Week
'What makes [Zimmerman's] book new is not only his extensive use of archival and secondary materials, but his attempt to provide a comprehensive synthesis over the whole period, from the formation of the ZWZ (Home Army) to the crushing of the Warsaw Uprising. In this he succeeds admirably.' Yad Vashem Studies
'Joshua Zimmerman's book ... is an important work on a topic that is among the central themes of Holocaust history ... There is a need for a historical study that presents a 'comprehensive treatment of different patterns of behavior towards the Jews at different times during the war and in various regions of occupied Poland' ... Zimmerman's book is an important attempt to present such a study in English, and he succeeds in his aim to maintain 'an absolute commitment to strive for impartiality'.' Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs
'The war was over, but the legacy of that period continues to haunt Polish-Jewish relations. It is therefore vital to have a book like Zimmerman's that so judiciously analyzes relations between the Polish Underground and the Jews and brings a full sense of their complexity to the debate. This is a book richly deserving of praise.' Eva Plach, Slavic Review
'Zimmerman has set a standard of comprehensiveness, excellence, meticulousness, and balance. While the content of this work is exceedingly disquieting, the work of the historian is deeply satisfying.' Michael Berenbaum, Holocaust and Genocide Studies
'Joshua Zimmerman has bravely taken on this controversial topic and has produced a remarkably fair, objective, and scholarly monograph. For anyone interested in a careful and nuanced view of this difficult period in Polish and Jewish history, this book is essential ... Joshua Zimmerman's The Polish Underground and the Jews is a major contribution to this history. It is required reading for anyone wishing to understand some of the darkest days in Polish history which, however, also witnessed astonishing acts of decency and heroism. Essential.' Theodore R. Weeks, The Polish Review
'Some books are timely, others are useful and still others are good. Joshua D. Zimmerman's The Polish Underground and the Jews 1939-1945 is all three ... Zimmerman has set a standard of comprehensiveness, excellence, meticulousness and balance. While the content of this work is exceedingly disquieting, the work of the historian is deeply satisfying.' Michael Berenbaum, Jewish Journal
'... Zimmerman's book is a major contribution to scholarship ... it is the work of a professional academic writing for other specialists.' Ben Barkow, The Jewish Chronicle
'This study is essential reading for modern Polish history and the Holocaust, complicating narratives about local agency in thwarting and executing German genocidal plans. It provides a framework for the expanding literature on Polish behavior in local communities during the Holocaust ... the majority of the book's readers will no doubt be interested in occupied Poland and the Holocaust, those studying underground movements and partisan warfare should also find this a provocative and important study.' Jadwiga Biskupska, H-Poland
Book Information
ISBN 9781107014268
Author Joshua D. Zimmerman
Format Hardback
Page Count 474
Imprint Cambridge University Press
Publisher Cambridge University Press
Weight(grams) 1050g
Dimensions(mm) 262mm * 185mm * 30mm
Zimmerman examines the attitude and behavior of the Polish Underground towards the Jews during the Holocaust.
About the Author
Joshua D. Zimmerman is an Associate Professor of History and the Eli and Diana Zborowski Professorial Chair in Holocaust Studies and East European Jewish History at Yeshiva University in New York. He is the author of Poles, Jews and the Politics of Nationality: The Bund and the Polish Socialist Party in Late Tsarist Russia (2003) and the editor of two contributed volumes: Contested Memories: Poles and Jews during the Holocaust and its Aftermath (2003) and Jews in Italy under Fascist and Nazi Rule, 1922-1945 (Cambridge, 2005).
Reviews
'This is a superb history of one of the oddest episodes of World War II. Zimmerman has emerged as one of the best experts on the history of the controversial Polish-Jewish relations. His matter-of-fact style further dramatizes the Polish-Jewish affairs during World War II when the Polish underground army heroically fought against the Nazis, sometimes killing and sometimes helping the Jews who also participated in the anti-Nazi struggle. A shocking drama and a wonderfully researched, documented and written book - a real page-turner.' Ivan T. Berend, Distinguished Professor of History, University of California, Los Angeles
'Joshua D. Zimmerman has chosen to deal with an extremely controversial topic. He has carried out his task with great sensitivity and intelligence. The attitude of the Home Army to Jews was complicated, varying from time to time and also from place to place. On the basis of original sources, Zimmerman demonstrates how difficult it is to make generalizations about aspects of Polish-Jewish relations. This is an exciting and important book.' Peter Kenez, Emeritus Professor of History, University of California, Santa Cruz
'This well-researched and clearly written monograph deals with a very important but inadequately investigated topic - the reaction of the Armia Krajowa (Home Army) ... to the mass murder of the Jews carried out by Nazi Germany in Poland. Although the topic has aroused considerable controversy ... it has never been subject to a full scholarly investigation, making use of the large archival resources now available in Poland and abroad. This has now been accomplished by Professor Zimmerman. His approach is balanced and dispassionate and he consistently allows the documents to speak for themselves and to show all sides of a complex story. His book will, in my view, become the definitive account of the subject, which is crucial for an understanding the larger problem of the attitude of Polish society to the mass murder of Polish Jews carried out on Polish soil.' Antony Polonsky, Emeritus Professor of Holocaust Studies, Brandeis University, and Chief Historian, POLIN Museum of the History of Polish Jews, Warsaw
'Joshua Zimmerman's [book] is not only the most recent addition to the growing field of historical study of Polish-Jewish relations in World War II, but is also certainly the most complete in current literature. Brilliantly combining the divergent perspective of the Polish underground leadership and of the Jewish resistance, and accounting for their internal diversity, Zimmerman presents the stark choices each actor had to face, and why what was best to one was often seen as detrimental to the other. Skilfully combining analyses of pre-war and wartime Polish politics, military choices, anti-Semitism, the impact of the German genocide, and the perspective of liberation/occupation at the hands of the Soviets, as well as personal world-views of the individual commanders, the monograph explains why not enough help was forthcoming from the Polish side, and why Jews were perceived, and sometimes perceived themselves, as no longer being part of it.' Konstanty Gebert, Gazeta Wyborcza, Warsaw
'Zimmerman's book is a masterpiece. Zimmerman joins the ranks of other great Jewish historians who have published outstanding works on Polish-Jewish wartime relations free of prejudice.' Filip Mazurczak, Visegrad Insight
'[Zimmerman's] neutrality, painstaking dedication and fluency in Polish [has] helped him sift through the various cobwebs of perception on both sides and gain access to files others would never have found.' Haaretz (Haaretz.com)
'Zimmerman's book offers a balanced perspective, personalizing the topic by presenting profiles of several righteous individuals as well as unrepentant anti-Semites.' Steve Lipman, The Jewish Week
'What makes [Zimmerman's] book new is not only his extensive use of archival and secondary materials, but his attempt to provide a comprehensive synthesis over the whole period, from the formation of the ZWZ (Home Army) to the crushing of the Warsaw Uprising. In this he succeeds admirably.' Yad Vashem Studies
'Joshua Zimmerman's book ... is an important work on a topic that is among the central themes of Holocaust history ... There is a need for a historical study that presents a 'comprehensive treatment of different patterns of behavior towards the Jews at different times during the war and in various regions of occupied Poland' ... Zimmerman's book is an important attempt to present such a study in English, and he succeeds in his aim to maintain 'an absolute commitment to strive for impartiality'.' Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs
'The war was over, but the legacy of that period continues to haunt Polish-Jewish relations. It is therefore vital to have a book like Zimmerman's that so judiciously analyzes relations between the Polish Underground and the Jews and brings a full sense of their complexity to the debate. This is a book richly deserving of praise.' Eva Plach, Slavic Review
'Zimmerman has set a standard of comprehensiveness, excellence, meticulousness, and balance. While the content of this work is exceedingly disquieting, the work of the historian is deeply satisfying.' Michael Berenbaum, Holocaust and Genocide Studies
'Joshua Zimmerman has bravely taken on this controversial topic and has produced a remarkably fair, objective, and scholarly monograph. For anyone interested in a careful and nuanced view of this difficult period in Polish and Jewish history, this book is essential ... Joshua Zimmerman's The Polish Underground and the Jews is a major contribution to this history. It is required reading for anyone wishing to understand some of the darkest days in Polish history which, however, also witnessed astonishing acts of decency and heroism. Essential.' Theodore R. Weeks, The Polish Review
'Some books are timely, others are useful and still others are good. Joshua D. Zimmerman's The Polish Underground and the Jews 1939-1945 is all three ... Zimmerman has set a standard of comprehensiveness, excellence, meticulousness and balance. While the content of this work is exceedingly disquieting, the work of the historian is deeply satisfying.' Michael Berenbaum, Jewish Journal
'... Zimmerman's book is a major contribution to scholarship ... it is the work of a professional academic writing for other specialists.' Ben Barkow, The Jewish Chronicle
'This study is essential reading for modern Polish history and the Holocaust, complicating narratives about local agency in thwarting and executing German genocidal plans. It provides a framework for the expanding literature on Polish behavior in local communities during the Holocaust ... the majority of the book's readers will no doubt be interested in occupied Poland and the Holocaust, those studying underground movements and partisan warfare should also find this a provocative and important study.' Jadwiga Biskupska, H-Poland
Book Information
ISBN 9781107014268
Author Joshua D. Zimmerman
Format Hardback
Page Count 474
Imprint Cambridge University Press
Publisher Cambridge University Press
Weight(grams) 1050g
Dimensions(mm) 262mm * 185mm * 30mm
