Description
David Boonin presents a new account of the non-identity problem: a puzzle about our obligations to people who do not yet exist. Our actions sometimes have an effect not only on the quality of life that people will enjoy in the future, but on which particular people will exist in the future to enjoy it. In cases where this is so, the combination of certain assumptions that most people seem to accept can yield conclusions that most people seem to reject. The non-identity problem has important implications both for ethical theory and for a number of topics in applied ethics, including controversial issues in bioethics, environmental ethics and disability ethics. It has been the subject of a great deal of discussion for nearly four decades, but this is the first book-length study devoted exclusively to its examination. Boonin begins by explaining what the problem is, why the problem matters, and what criteria a solution to the problem must satisfy in order to count as a successful one. He then provides a critical survey of the solutions to the problem that have thus far been proposed in the sizeable literature that the problem has generated and concludes by developing and defending an unorthodox alternative solution, one that differs fundamentally from virtually every other available approach.
About the Author
David Boonin is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Colorado. He received his BA from Yale University and his PhD from the University of Pittsburgh. Boonin is the author of Thomas Hobbes and the Science of Moral Virtue (CUP, 1994), A Defense of Abortion (CUP, 2003), The Problem of Punishment (CUP, 2008), Should Race Matter? (CUP, 2011), Beyond Roe: Why Abortion Should be Legal Even if the Fetus is a Person (OUP, 2019), and Dead Wrong: The Ethics of Posthumous Harm (OUP, 2019) as well as a number of articles on such subjects as animal rights, euthanasia, same-sex marriage, and our moral obligations to past and future generations. He is also the editor of the Palgrave Handbook of Philosophy and Public Policy (Palgrave 2018), the co-author and co-editor, with his colleague Graham Oddie, of the popular textbook What's Wrong?: Applied Ethicists and Their Critics (OUP, 2009 (second edition)), and the current Editor of Public Affairs Quarterly.
Reviews
Review from previous edition A model of philosophical reasoning . . . his argument is highly compelling. His negative arguments are thorough, clear, and insightful, and his positive arguments are illuminating. Anyone whose research relates to the non-identity problem -- and given the interdisciplinary nature of the problem, that is a large number of people -- would be well advised to read this book. * Molly Gardner, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews *
important . . . argues for surprising and controversial conclusions * Fiona Woollard, Analysis *
David Boonin's new book provides a wonderful opportunity to take a fresh look at what is perhaps the most important problem ever to arise within the area of population ethics. Brilliantly argued, perfectly organized, fascinating in content and accessible to a broad range of readers, The Non-Identity Problem and the Ethics of Future People marks a critical turning point in our efforts to understand the structure of moral law. * Melinda A. Roberts, The College of New Jersey, co-author of Harming Future Persons *
For almost forty years, philosophers have searched for an explanation of why it is wrong for us to bring about the existence of worse- rather than better-off people. In this thorough and methodical book, David Boonin argues that this search is misguided. He systematically reviews all the explanations that have been offered (at least all I know of), and makes a strong case that they either fail to explain the assumed wrong or explain it in ways that have even more implausible implications than denying the wrong. Some books are seminal, opening up a new field or inquiry; this book could be called terminal, cogently arguing that we abandon a search that has been pursued with great resourcefulness and tenacity. Boonin leaves us with a conclusion that many will find disturbing, but some will find liberating: that we face far fewer moral constraints in the creation of future people than we commonly suppose * David Wasserman *
Throughout this careful examination, Boonin employs thoughtful case studies and thought experiments that serve to engage the reader in the analysis. The result is a book that is likely to put this philosophical quandary to rest ... Essential. * Choice *
Book Information
ISBN 9780198866855
Author David Boonin
Format Paperback
Page Count 320
Imprint Oxford University Press
Publisher Oxford University Press
Dimensions(mm) 234mm * 156mm * 18mm
About the Author
David Boonin is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Colorado. He received his BA from Yale University and his PhD from the University of Pittsburgh. Boonin is the author of Thomas Hobbes and the Science of Moral Virtue (CUP, 1994), A Defense of Abortion (CUP, 2003), The Problem of Punishment (CUP, 2008), Should Race Matter? (CUP, 2011), Beyond Roe: Why Abortion Should be Legal Even if the Fetus is a Person (OUP, 2019), and Dead Wrong: The Ethics of Posthumous Harm (OUP, 2019) as well as a number of articles on such subjects as animal rights, euthanasia, same-sex marriage, and our moral obligations to past and future generations. He is also the editor of the Palgrave Handbook of Philosophy and Public Policy (Palgrave 2018), the co-author and co-editor, with his colleague Graham Oddie, of the popular textbook What's Wrong?: Applied Ethicists and Their Critics (OUP, 2009 (second edition)), and the current Editor of Public Affairs Quarterly.
Reviews
Review from previous edition A model of philosophical reasoning . . . his argument is highly compelling. His negative arguments are thorough, clear, and insightful, and his positive arguments are illuminating. Anyone whose research relates to the non-identity problem -- and given the interdisciplinary nature of the problem, that is a large number of people -- would be well advised to read this book. * Molly Gardner, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews *
important . . . argues for surprising and controversial conclusions * Fiona Woollard, Analysis *
David Boonin's new book provides a wonderful opportunity to take a fresh look at what is perhaps the most important problem ever to arise within the area of population ethics. Brilliantly argued, perfectly organized, fascinating in content and accessible to a broad range of readers, The Non-Identity Problem and the Ethics of Future People marks a critical turning point in our efforts to understand the structure of moral law. * Melinda A. Roberts, The College of New Jersey, co-author of Harming Future Persons *
For almost forty years, philosophers have searched for an explanation of why it is wrong for us to bring about the existence of worse- rather than better-off people. In this thorough and methodical book, David Boonin argues that this search is misguided. He systematically reviews all the explanations that have been offered (at least all I know of), and makes a strong case that they either fail to explain the assumed wrong or explain it in ways that have even more implausible implications than denying the wrong. Some books are seminal, opening up a new field or inquiry; this book could be called terminal, cogently arguing that we abandon a search that has been pursued with great resourcefulness and tenacity. Boonin leaves us with a conclusion that many will find disturbing, but some will find liberating: that we face far fewer moral constraints in the creation of future people than we commonly suppose * David Wasserman *
Throughout this careful examination, Boonin employs thoughtful case studies and thought experiments that serve to engage the reader in the analysis. The result is a book that is likely to put this philosophical quandary to rest ... Essential. * Choice *
Book Information
ISBN 9780198866855
Author David Boonin
Format Paperback
Page Count 320
Imprint Oxford University Press
Publisher Oxford University Press
Dimensions(mm) 234mm * 156mm * 18mm
