Description
A history of "priming" research that analyzes the field's underlying assumptions and experimental protocols to shed new light on a contemporary crisis in social psychology.
In 2012, a team of Belgian scientists reported that they had been unable to replicate a canonical experiment in the field of psychology known as "priming." The original experiment, performed by John Bargh in the nineties, had purported to show that words connoting old age unconsciously influenced-or primed-research subjects, causing them to walk more slowly. When subsequent researchers could not replicate these results, Nobel-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman warned of a "train wreck looming" if Bargh and his colleagues could not address doubts about their work. Since then, the inability to replicate other well-known priming experiments has helped precipitate an ongoing debate over what has gone wrong in psychology, raising fundamental questions about the soundness of research practices in the field.
Anatomy of a Train Wreck offers the first detailed history of priming research from its origins in the early 1980s to its recent collapse. Ruth Leys places priming experiments in the context of contemporaneous debates over not only the nature of automaticity but also the very foundations of social psychology. While these latest discussions about priming have largely focused on methodology-including sloppy experimental practices, inadequate statistical methods, and publication bias-Leys offers a genealogy of the theoretical expectations and scientific paradigms that have guided and motivated priming research itself. Examining scientists' intellectual strategies, their responses to criticism, and their assumptions about the nature of subjectivity, Anatomy of a Train Wreck raises crucial questions about the evidence surrounding unconscious influence and probes the larger stakes of the replication crisis: psychology's status as a science.
About the Author
Ruth Leys is professor emerita of the humanities at Johns Hopkins University. She is the author of Trauma: A Genealogy, From Guilt to Shame: Auschwitz and After, The Ascent of Affect: Genealogy and Critique, and Newborn Imitation: The Stakes of a Controversy.
Reviews
"Leys provides a thrilling intellectual history of the rise and fall of research on the automaticity of everyday behavior and exposes how highly acclaimed science went astray. The idea that individual agency is an illusion, documented by priming effects and propagated in the media worldwide, turned out to be an illusion itself. A meticulously researched, critical, and eye-opening book." -- Gerd Gigerenzer, Max Planck Institute for Human Development
"Leys is the sharpest interpreter of the neurosciences working in the humanities today. Her Anatomy of a Train Wreck contributes to a buzzing scholarship in critical neuroscience that spans the disciplines of history of science and science studies, anthropology, philosophy, and critical psychology. What makes her work stand out is that it is never solely focused on a critique of the neurosciences. Rather, Leys writes her critique with a firm grounding in the history and theory of psychoanalysis, which not only makes sense for her historical framing but gives nuance and vision to her arguments. In Anatomy of a Train Wreck, Leys deploys Freud's notion of the unconscious-used in skewed and partial ways by the historical actors-to sketch a richer view of intentionality, pointing the way to an epistemology that can capture the complexity of human behavior." -- Katja Guenther, Princeton University
Book Information
ISBN 9780226836959
Author Ruth Leys
Format Paperback
Page Count 384
Imprint University of Chicago Press
Publisher The University of Chicago Press
Weight(grams) 454g
In 2012, a team of Belgian scientists reported that they had been unable to replicate a canonical experiment in the field of psychology known as "priming." The original experiment, performed by John Bargh in the nineties, had purported to show that words connoting old age unconsciously influenced-or primed-research subjects, causing them to walk more slowly. When subsequent researchers could not replicate these results, Nobel-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman warned of a "train wreck looming" if Bargh and his colleagues could not address doubts about their work. Since then, the inability to replicate other well-known priming experiments has helped precipitate an ongoing debate over what has gone wrong in psychology, raising fundamental questions about the soundness of research practices in the field.
Anatomy of a Train Wreck offers the first detailed history of priming research from its origins in the early 1980s to its recent collapse. Ruth Leys places priming experiments in the context of contemporaneous debates over not only the nature of automaticity but also the very foundations of social psychology. While these latest discussions about priming have largely focused on methodology-including sloppy experimental practices, inadequate statistical methods, and publication bias-Leys offers a genealogy of the theoretical expectations and scientific paradigms that have guided and motivated priming research itself. Examining scientists' intellectual strategies, their responses to criticism, and their assumptions about the nature of subjectivity, Anatomy of a Train Wreck raises crucial questions about the evidence surrounding unconscious influence and probes the larger stakes of the replication crisis: psychology's status as a science.
About the Author
Ruth Leys is professor emerita of the humanities at Johns Hopkins University. She is the author of Trauma: A Genealogy, From Guilt to Shame: Auschwitz and After, The Ascent of Affect: Genealogy and Critique, and Newborn Imitation: The Stakes of a Controversy.
Reviews
"Leys provides a thrilling intellectual history of the rise and fall of research on the automaticity of everyday behavior and exposes how highly acclaimed science went astray. The idea that individual agency is an illusion, documented by priming effects and propagated in the media worldwide, turned out to be an illusion itself. A meticulously researched, critical, and eye-opening book." -- Gerd Gigerenzer, Max Planck Institute for Human Development
"Leys is the sharpest interpreter of the neurosciences working in the humanities today. Her Anatomy of a Train Wreck contributes to a buzzing scholarship in critical neuroscience that spans the disciplines of history of science and science studies, anthropology, philosophy, and critical psychology. What makes her work stand out is that it is never solely focused on a critique of the neurosciences. Rather, Leys writes her critique with a firm grounding in the history and theory of psychoanalysis, which not only makes sense for her historical framing but gives nuance and vision to her arguments. In Anatomy of a Train Wreck, Leys deploys Freud's notion of the unconscious-used in skewed and partial ways by the historical actors-to sketch a richer view of intentionality, pointing the way to an epistemology that can capture the complexity of human behavior." -- Katja Guenther, Princeton University
Book Information
ISBN 9780226836959
Author Ruth Leys
Format Paperback
Page Count 384
Imprint University of Chicago Press
Publisher The University of Chicago Press
Weight(grams) 454g
